Lumpsum vs SIP: Which Is Better? A Worked Example With ₹12 Lakh

Bar chart comparing a 12 lakh rupee lump sum with a 10,000 rupee monthly SIP over 10 years

Short answer: If you already have the money, a lump sum has more time to grow: ₹12 lakh invested once for 10 years at an assumed 12% becomes ₹37,27,018, while ₹10,000 a month for 10 years (also ₹12 lakh in total) becomes ₹23,23,391. But a SIP spreads your risk over time and suits regular income. Neither is guaranteed.

The difference in one sentence

A lump sum puts all your money to work on day one. A SIP puts it to work in small parts over many months. That is why, when you compare the same total amount at the same assumed return, the lump sum almost always shows a higher number. The more useful question is not which number is bigger, but which method fits your money and your nerves.

The same ₹12 lakh, two ways

Take ₹12 lakh. In one case you invest all of it today. In the other you invest ₹10,000 a month for 10 years, which is also ₹12 lakh in total. These are the projected values at three assumed returns, from the lumpsum calculator and the SIP calculator.

Assumed returnLump sum of ₹12 lakh₹10,000 a month
8%₹25,90,710₹18,41,657
10%₹31,12,491₹20,65,520
12%₹37,27,018₹23,23,391
Lumpsum at 8%₹25,90,710SIP at 8%₹18,41,657Lumpsum at 10%₹31,12,491SIP at 10%₹20,65,520Lumpsum at 12%₹37,27,018SIP at 12%₹23,23,391
Same ₹12 lakh in total. Returns are assumed, not guaranteed.

The lump sum wins every time, because most of the SIP money is invested for far less than 10 years. The last instalment grows for one month only. This is not a flaw in the SIP. It is simply what happens when money arrives late. (The lumpsum calculator adds returns once a year and the SIP calculator adds them every month, so the two are not perfectly like for like, but the gap is large enough that the conclusion holds.)

Where a SIP is better

  • You do not have the lump sum. Most people earn month by month, and a SIP is how that income gets invested.
  • You worry about timing. A lump sum invested just before a market fall hurts. A SIP buys at many prices, so no single month decides the result.
  • You want a habit. A SIP runs automatically. See how raising it each year adds more in the step-up SIP guide.

Where a lump sum is better

  • You have a bonus or maturity money that would otherwise sit in a savings account at a low rate.
  • The horizon is long, 10 years or more, so a temporary fall has time to recover.
  • The market looks cheap to you. Be careful: nobody can reliably time it.

A middle path: spread the lump sum

If you have a large sum and fear investing it all at once, you can park it in a safer fund and move a fixed amount into your equity fund each month for 6 to 12 months. This is called an STP (systematic transfer plan). It reduces the chance of putting everything in just before a fall, at the cost of leaving some money out of the market for a while.

What to check before you decide

  • The goal date. Money needed within 3 to 5 years should not go into equity either way.
  • Your emergency fund. See how much you need.
  • Tax. Equity fund gains held for more than 12 months are taxed at 12.5% above ₹1.25 lakh a year at the rates in force for FY 2026-27, and gains held for 12 months or less at 20%. Check the current rules.
  • The return you really earned. Use the CAGR calculator.

Keep reading

Frequently asked questions

Is lumpsum better than SIP?

For the same total amount and the same assumed return, a lump sum grows more because it is invested earlier. A SIP is better if you earn monthly, or want to spread the risk of timing.

Should I invest a lump sum in a falling market?

Nobody can predict the market. Many investors split a lump sum into a few instalments or use an STP to reduce the risk of bad timing.

Can I do both a lump sum and a SIP?

Yes. Many people keep a SIP going from salary and add a lump sum when they receive a bonus.

Are the returns guaranteed?

No. The calculators show what would happen at the return you type in. Real returns vary from year to year.

Sources: SEBI Investor Website — mutual fund investor education · AMFI — Association of Mutual Funds in India · Income Tax Department

For education only. This guide explains how the rules work and is not financial, tax or legal advice. Rates and rules change, so check the sources above. See our disclaimer and editorial policy.